DCNH system and MBTI types. / Система DCNH и типы MBTI. Вопрос соционику Гуленко

Ответ на вопрос визитера

Jared Vaughan

10 июля 2023 г.

According to DCNH Dominant types enhance Te, Fe, Se Creative types enhance Ne, Se, Fe Normalizing types enance Ti, Fi, Si Harmonizing types enhance Si, Ni, Fi I agree with Gulenko on 10 of these 12. But I would move Ni to normalizing and Ti to harmonizing. Why? Because then they match the lead function of all of Keirsey/Beren\'s interaction styles types. Which is what DCNH indirectly stems from. With Dominant resembling in charge types. Creative resembling get things going types. Normalizing resembling chart the course types. Harmonizing representing behind the scenes types.
So: In charge types = ESTJ (Te lead), ENTJ (Te), ESTP (Se), ENFJ (Fe) Get things going = ENTP (Ne), ENFP (Ne), ESFP (Se), ESFJ (Fe) Chart the course = INTp (Ni), INFp (Ni), ISTJ (Ti), ISTP (Si) Behind the scenes = INFj (Fi), ISFJ (Fi), ISFP (Si), INTj (Ti) I would argue that Gulenko should rewrite the DCNH cognitive function correlations as: D = Te (also Se- and Fe-) C = Ne (also Se+, Fe+) N = Ni (also Ti+ and Si-) H = Fi (also Ti- and Si+) Ni is more Normalizing because it seeks to link the future with the past. And Ti- is more harmonizing because it seeks to merge and harmonize theories.

Виктор Гуленко

DCNH-система была разработана ещё в начале 90-х годов и не имеет никакого отношения к типам MBTI. Она выведена из практических экспериментов с малыми группами, которые показали существенную разницу в поведении людей одного и того же типа в одинаковых ситуациях.

Существовании таких различий подтверждено независимыми исследованиями ЭЭГ типов известного американского учёного Дарио Нарди. Также не следует забывать, что кроме усиления нескольких функций в DCNH существуют специальные дихотомии (например, инициальность – терминальность), которые задают подтип независимо от положения функций в типе.

Будьте ближе к нам:

Все консультации Задать вопрос

♦

Gulenko does not read comments

16.07.2023 10:24

Jared, I suggest this article to help understand the difference between Ti and Ni in LII and ILI https://socioniks.net/article/?id=230 .
MB-variants fails to understand introverted types due to misunderstanding Rationality/Irrationality in introverts.

Nardi does not help the situation when he mistypes himself and bases most of his commercial publications on his mistyped foundation. If you read his book with an understanding of Socionics you can see how key brain regions are incorrectly attributed due to this bias.

I would phrase this as a question to Gulenko himself, however he is notoriously spineless in answering anything that may be considered controversial or cause tensions with "well-known" people. Gulenko seems far more Harmonizing than any other subtype: unwilling to directly and categorically correct misunderstandings promoted by people like Naridi in preference of everything being non-contentious and peaceful.

So endless suggested revisions of systems occur instead.

Gulenko does not read comments

16.07.2023 10:23

Jared, I suggest this article to help understand the difference between Ti and Ni in LII and ILI https://socioniks.net/article/?id=230 .
MB-variants fails to understand introverted types due to misunderstanding Rationality/Irrationality in introverts.

Nardi does not help the situation when he mistypes himself and bases most of his commercial publications on his mistyped foundation. If you read his book with an understanding of Socionics you can see how key brain regions are incorrectly attributed due to this bias.

I would phrase this as a question to Gulenko himself, however he is notoriously spineless in answering anything that may be considered controversial or cause tensions with "well-known" people. Gulenko seems far more Harmonizing than any other subtype: unwilling to directly and categorically correct misunderstandings promoted by people like Naridi in preference of everything being non-contentious and peaceful.

So endless suggested revisions of systems occur instead.

Осталось 1000 символов

Не пропустите, это тоже

Интересно

♦

Подтипы

Подтипы в соционике. Квадра Альфа. Тип Посредник (Дюма, СЭИ) – креативный, доминантный, нормик и гармоник

Подтипы квадры Альфа в соционике. Тип Посредник (Дюма, СЭИ) – креативный, доминантный, нормирующий и гармонизирующий подтипы. Доминантный подтип...

1

34344

Статьи

Сравнение типов Критик и Аналитик. Компаративная соционика. INTP и INTJ в MBTI

Сравнение типов Критик и Аналитик в Гуманитарной соционике. Компаративная соционика. Как типы INTP и INTJ в MBTI...

4

47283

Статьи

Психическая энергия, что это такое?

На физическом уровне – это активность нейронов, а также инстинкты и рефлексы организма, связанные с выживанием и размножением...

3

15376

Подтипы

Система подтипов DCNH Гуманитарной соционики в сравнении с типологиями MBTI, Big Five, DISC

Пока мою теорию подтипов (DCNH Гуманитарной соционики) упорно отрицали как не имеющую отношения к соционике, западные типологии MBTI, Big Five, DISC...

4

25196